Home Business Osisko Gold Royalties: A Filth-Affordable Valuation For This Prime-Margin Industry

Osisko Gold Royalties: A Filth-Affordable Valuation For This Prime-Margin Industry

Osisko Gold Royalties: A Filth-Affordable Valuation For This Prime-Margin Industry

Falcor/E+ by means of Getty Photographs

Previous this yr, I wrote on Osisko Gold Royalties (NYSE:OR), noting that the inventory introduced an extraordinary mixture of expansion and price. I finished up timing this name very poorly, with the inventory sinking 30% since my April replace. Then again, out of doors of a reasonably susceptible gold/silver value, I do not see any trade to the funding thesis, for the reason that Osisko Gold Royalties has an inflation-resistant enterprise style and is not seeing margin contraction like a few of its manufacturer friends. So, with OR at the fireplace sale rack (~0.80x P/NAV) and paying a ~2.0% dividend yield, I see the inventory as a scouse borrow, and I have persevered to acquire on weak spot.

Canadian Malartic Mine

Canadian Malartic Mine (3-5% NSR held via OR) (Agnico Eagle Presentation)

Whilst the Osisko Gold Royalties (“Osisko GR”) funding thesis used to be already horny with a brand new movement at the international’s highest-grade gold mine in Utah, and several other royalties/streams on horny Tier-1 jurisdiction property, the tale has simplest develop into higher since Q2. It’s because the Canadian Malartic Partnership continues to have drilling luck at Osisko GR’s flagship assets, Osisko Mining (OTCPK:OBNNF) simply unveiled additional expansion in grades and measurement at its Providence deposit, and Agnico Eagle (AEM) continues to churn out loose money glide, boding effectively for increased exploration spend throughout a number of homes the place Osisko GR holds royalties.

On this replace, despite the fact that, I consider it is sensible to concentrate on its flagship royalty, Canadian Malartic, and have a look at the actual worth of this asset according to one of the transactions now we have noticed within the royalty house during the last yr (Nice Undergo Undertaking, Cortez, and many others.). Given the exploration luck at Canadian Malartic, this asset on my own makes up an enormous portion of Osisko’s internet asset worth and is being improperly priced inside its portfolio according to the place the marketplace is valuing the corporate. Actually, given how horny this asset is (having the possible to ship 30,000-plus GEOs in keeping with annum over the following twenty years), I am shocked that Osisko GR does not have a goal on its again from higher royalty firms having a look to scoop up its portfolio in a takeover state of affairs.

Canadian Malartic

Canadian Malartic is arguably one of the vital horny royalties within the gold house. Then again, whilst Franco Nevada (FNV) has a 1.5% internet smelter go back [NSR] royalty at the mine, Osisko GR has a three.0% – 5.0% NSR royalty on Odyssey, with its absolute best royalty charge on East Gouldie, the breadwinner of the deposit with the absolute best grades. So, whilst exploration luck at Canadian Malartic advantages firms like Franco Nevada, it has an oversized have an effect on on Osisko GR, which has a miles higher royalty and is far smaller, which means the spice up to its internet asset worth is that a lot more important.

Odyssey Underground

Odyssey Underground (3-5% NSR held via OR) (Agnico Eagle Presentation)

For the ones dwelling beneath a rock, the Canadian Malartic Partnership [CMP] selected to construct Canada’s greatest underground mine, Odyssey, in Q1 2021, extending the lifetime of the Canadian Malartic Mine to 2039. The $1.3 billion challenge (according to 3 spaces: East Gouldie, East Malartic, Odyssey) used to be anticipated to churn out ~550,000 oz. of gold from 2029-2039 at sub $650/ounces money prices, making it one of the vital successful mines globally. Then again, you need to notice that they made up our minds to construct this mine on simply ~6.9 million oz. of anticipated manufacturing. Lately, Odyssey is house to ~15.5 million oz. of gold, and I’d now not be shocked to peer it surpass the 22.0 million-ounce mark (reserves and sources blended) via year-end 2026.

Canadian Malartic Historical Production & Resource Growth

Canadian Malartic Historic Manufacturing & Useful resource Enlargement (Yamana Presentation)

Recently, the challenge is monitoring consistent with its time table and funds, with shaft sinking to start in This autumn 2022 and the primary gold made out of Odyssey South anticipated in H1 2023. Then again, probably the most thrilling building is the exploration luck right here. All over Q2, we won a number of new spotlight intercepts from Odyssey from the CMP. Whilst now not indicative of reasonable grade drilled (those are spotlight holes), they are out of the ordinary and effectively above the common useful resource grades of three.0 grams in keeping with tonne at East Gouldie and a pair of.1 grams in keeping with tonne at Odyssey South. Actually, those are one of the highest holes I have noticed out of Odyssey South because the CMP pursued the underground alternative.

East Gouldie Infill Drilling Highlights

  • MEX21-230WB, 6.45 g/t of gold over 22.53 meters;
  • MEX22-233, 5.03 g/t of gold over 33.24 meters;
  • MEX21-225WBZ, 2.23 g/t of gold over 60.26 meters; and
  • MEX21-228W, 6.93 g/t of gold over 27.50 meters.

Odyssey South Infill Drilling Highlights

  • UGOD-021-007, 19.11 g/t of gold over 7.40 meters;
  • UGOD-021-002, 5.24 g/t of gold over 17.04 meters;
  • UGOD-026-010, 17.57 g/t of gold over 8.64 meters; and
  • UGOD-016-051, 28.66 g/t of gold over 6.62 meters.

The takeaways are as follows:

1. In just about all zones, however particularly East Gouldie, infill drilling is assembly and exceeding expectancies, and the inferred useful resource is predicted to be expanded, suggesting significant expansion in indicated sources (with extra to be transformed to reserves down the street), and a possible slight grade carry at those underground deposits. For now, reserves must be declared within the core portion of Odyssey South at year-end. This may considerably spice up Osisko GR’s attributable reserves and build up self belief within the Odyssey mine plan with reserves declared.

Canadian Malartic

Canadian Malartic (Yamana Gold Presentation)

2. There may be transparent doable to the west of East Gouldie with MEX-22-231 hitting 63 meters of one.8 grams in keeping with tonne gold, probably connecting East Gouldie with different zones (Norrie/Sladen) the place no mineral sources are recently provide. As well as, the sheer measurement of this residue and long-term doable can’t be overstated, with the private and easternmost drill hollow (RD-21-4689-AA) hitting 7.9 meters at 4.11 grams in keeping with tonne gold, consistent with the common grade of East Gouldie, and being 1,700 meters east of the present mineral useful resource define.

Canadian Malartic Exploration

Canadian Malartic Exploration (Agnico Eagle Presentation)

It is a huge step-out, particularly for a deposit that is already house to twelve million inferred oz. (East Gouldie). If drilling luck continues, the jap extension of East Gouldie may upload a number of million oz. to the CM useful resource stock, pushing the full useful resource above the 20.0-plus million ounce mark. Then again, as mentioned, there is additionally doable to the west of East Gouldie so as to add oz. and substantial upside around the assets the place the CMP is on the lookout for further mineralization.

So, why is that this necessary?

Canadian Malartic [CM] is recently a ~700,000-ounce in keeping with annum manufacturer, however the procedure plant is predicted to scale down materially as open-pit oz. are depleted. This may depart an extra ~40,000 tonnes of extra capability on the mill later this decade. So, whilst the underneath chart would possibly now not encourage self belief for an organization with a royalty in this asset, for the reason that annual manufacturing is declining, it’s worthwhile to make the next level. Even if manufacturing is declining from 700,000-plus oz. to ~550,000 oz. at CM, this mine plan is 2 years previous, and the mine might see decrease manufacturing, however it is churning out those 550,000 oz. with kind of one-third of the historic tonnes processed (for the reason that grades are such a lot upper underground). The result’s that there is important extra capability sitting on the mill.

Canadian Malartic Mine Plan

Canadian Malartic Mine Plan (CM Partnership Technical Document)

If the CMP had 20 rigs at the assets that had been depressing grades and had been suffering so as to add any sources, I’d be a lot much less positive about CM’s long term. Then again, it seems like the CMP may in the long run turn out up greater than 22 million oz. of sources and over 15 million oz. of reserves, which might give this mine a ~25-year lifestyles at a ~550,000-ounce run charge. There may be additionally the possible to delineate lower-grade subject matter that might be financial even underneath 0.90 gram in keeping with tonne gold near-surface, given the sunk prices with a mill proper subsequent door. So, quite than processing a majority of these sources over 30 years, Yamana (AUY) has been discussing the potential of a 2d shaft and pulling ahead oz..

That is conceptual in nature, and it is nonetheless early days, however it might be logical for the reason that any oz. 15-plus years one day have little worth from an NPV perspective with a 5% cut price charge implemented to them. Assume we think a 2d shaft is sunk close to the tip of this decade and think an extra 15,000 tonnes in keeping with day of subject matter is fed to the mill (2.1 grams in keeping with tonne at a 94% restoration charge). If that’s the case, this would upload ~340,000 oz. to the manufacturing profile on peak of the ~550,000-ounce manufacturing profile. Therefore, Canadian Malartic may grow to be right into a 900,000-ounce manufacturer and Canada’s greatest or 2d greatest mine (relying on Detour Lake’s manufacturing profile), even larger than it used to be as an open-pit operation.

Canadian Malartic Second Shaft Discussion

Canadian Malartic 2nd Shaft Dialogue (Yamana Gold Presentation )

Whilst this can be a longer-term alternative, for the reason that we are nonetheless running on shaft No. 1, this is able to considerably spice up OR’s manufacturing profile, with an efficient 4.40% NSR royalty on 900,000 oz. translating to ~39,600 oz. in keeping with annum from this one asset on my own. In comparison to the ~600,000-ounce manufacturing profile this decade, this is able to be an extra $23 million in income in keeping with annum at a $1,750/ounces gold value. It additionally would considerably spice up its consolidated internet asset worth, with oz. introduced ahead having the next worth and an extension to the mine lifestyles even at the next manufacturing charge.

Canadian Malartic Valuation

Whilst I’d now not worth an organization or asset only on what any other corporate has paid within the open marketplace for any other asset, it is transparent that royalty property held via huge well-financed operators in protected jurisdictions with substantial exploration upside are seeing a excessive price ticket. For instance, Royal Gold (RGLD) simply paid ~$2,000/ounces for its 1.20% NSR at the Cortez Complicated (Nevada Gold Mines JV) in Nevada. That is according to an estimated ~1.05 million oz. produced in keeping with annum over the following twenty years at Cortez (21.0 million oz. or 252,000 GEOs because of Royal Gold) with a $525 million price ticket. This determine is according to dividing $525 million via 252,000 GEOs dropped at Royal Gold within the subsequent twenty years.

If we examine this to Malartic, Malartic’s valuation on my own is staggering.

Once more, I’d warning towards the usage of the fee paid via one corporate to derive worth for any other asset. Nonetheless, the truthful worth most probably lies someplace between what Royal Gold paid and the place it is being valued. For my part, Malartic is arguably just about as spectacular an asset as Cortez, being in a protected jurisdiction (Quebec vs. Nevada), has a 20-year mine lifestyles, has huge exploration upside, and has two of the most important gold manufacturers answerable for the operation. As well as, I consider it has the possible to provide a median of 750,000 oz. in keeping with annum over the following twenty years.

At the floor, one would possibly right away conclude that Royal Gold’s royalty on Cortez that it simply bought is extra treasured, for the reason that Cortez will ramp as much as greater than 1.0 million oz. of gold manufacturing in keeping with annum with Goldrush, with additional expansion from Fourmile. Then again, Royal Gold’s NSR royalty is 1.2% on a 1.0+ million ounce manufacturing profile, and Osisko GR’s royalty is 3.5x the dimensions at ~4.40%. Therefore, this greater than offsets the decrease manufacturing profile. Subsequently, if Royal Gold used to be keen to pay $525 million for a 1.2% NSR on Cortez, and even though we used decrease multiples, that is striking a price on Canadian Malartic of greater than $1.05 billion if this royalty had been held on the market and given credit score for its growth case.

To summarize, one may argue that Osisko GR’s Canadian Malartic royalty on my own is value $5.67 in keeping with proportion (185 million stocks), which means that traders are purchasing the rest of the corporate for simply $3.58. This valuation would possibly make sense if Osisko GR had a susceptible royalty portfolio and not using a property to put in writing house about and no expansion. Then again, this is not the case in any respect. Actually, its Mantos silver movement, Eagle gold royalty, Providence gold royalty, and Renard Diamond movement on my own are value greater than $700 million blended from a internet asset worth perspective at a 1.20x NPV (5%) more than one, translating to $3.78 in keeping with proportion. Therefore, traders get the whole lot else within the portfolio without cost.

Osisko Gold Royalties - Producing Portfolio

Osisko Gold Royalties – Generating Portfolio (Corporate Presentation)

As proven above, the remainder of this portfolio could be very horny, with more than one royalty/streaming property on initiatives like Island Gold (present process a diffusion and set to be Canada’s lowest-cost mine), a big royalty on Seabee held via SSR Mining (SSRM), a decent-sized royalty on Eleonore, a mid-sized royalty on Bald Mountain, and a small royalty on Eldorado’s flagship Lamaque Mine. After all, Osisko has a brand new movement at the highest-grade gold mine globally, Tintic, the place Osisko Building is having a look to extend manufacturing materially, with the likelihood that it can be a 100,000-plus ounce manufacturer. Then again, what is out of doors of those generating royalties/streams and optionally holds substantial worth as effectively.

Tintic - T2/T4 Mineralization

Tintic – T2/T4 Mineralization (Osisko Building Presentation)

Trixie Mine Channel Samples

Trixie Mine Channel Samples (Osisko Building)

Those initiatives come with:

  • San Antonio (9,000+ GEOs in keeping with annum)
  • Cariboo (11,000+ GEOs in keeping with annum)
  • Higher Beaver (3,000+ GEOs in keeping with annum)
  • West Kenya (1,500+ GEOs)
  • Again 40 (9,000+ GEOs)
  • CSA Mine (5,000+ GEOs

There also are many different optionality initiatives like On line casino, Hammond Reef, Horne 5, and Hermosa that would upload any other 40,000-plus GEOs in keeping with annum. To be conservative, I’ve now not modeled those initiatives within the five-year manufacturing profile. Nonetheless, with conservative assumptions on initiatives with a excessive likelihood of constructing it into manufacturing, I see Osisko GR rising to 135,000-plus GEOs in FY2026 with out any more acquisitions. The above GEO figures are the estimated oz. because of Osisko GR as soon as in manufacturing.

Osisko vs. Peers - NAV by Country Risk

Osisko vs. Friends – NAV via Nation Chance (Corporate Presentation)

To summarize, with Canadian Malartic, Mantos, Eagle, Providence, and Renard making up simply ~60,000 GEOs in keeping with annum, traders are getting an excessively horny portfolio out of doors of those property at an excessively low charge, relying on how one chooses to price Canadian Malartic. This makes little sense, for the reason that those different 70,000+ GEOs in keeping with annum because of Osisko GR will generate over $120 million in income in keeping with annum at a $1,750/ounces gold value. Given the placement of unfavorable actual charges, I’d argue that this can be a conservative assumption, and I’d be expecting gold costs to be above $2,000/ounces in FY2026. Simply as importantly, Osisko’s royalties are situated in Tier-1 jurisdictions (Canada, Australia, United States), so there is not any concern about discounting them excessively because of jurisdictional chance.

Osisko Gold Royalties - Projected Production Profile

Osisko Gold Royalties – Projected Manufacturing Profile (Corporate Filings, Writer’s Chart)


Whilst Osisko GR’s present financials are noisy when consolidated with Osisko Building (ODV), the valuation right here may now not be extra horny, and I see a trail to a lot upper dividends post-2024 and 4 transparent catalysts for a re-rating:

  • the marketplace realizes that Malartic is in point of fact an 850,000+ ounce in keeping with annum asset, now not ~600,000 oz.
  • a de-consolidation of Osisko building which might blank up the financials
  • a a hit ramp as much as 250,000+ oz. at Eagle or building get started at Providence, either one of which upload 5,000+ GEOs in keeping with annum on an attributable foundation
  • persevered expansion in money glide from more than one initiatives around the portfolio, with Osisko GR having an industry-leading natural expansion profile

Given this horny profile and an estimated internet asset worth (even ignoring what Royal Gold paid for Cortez) of ~$2.3 billion and a P/NAV more than one of one.40 (effectively underneath Franco Nevada’s present more than one of one.90), I see an even worth for Osisko GR of US$17.40. This interprets to just about 100% upside from present ranges. For the reason that this can be a high-margin (90%-plus margins) royalty/streaming enterprise that is inflation-resistant, I see minimum drawback or execution chance. In my enjoy, the investments with substantial upside and restricted drawback are probably the most horny.

Because of this, I see the inventory as a Robust Purchase, and I’ve persevered to acquire OR on weak spot, making it a top-5 portfolio place. With the potential of a US$0.30 dividend long-term, Osisko GR now gives an access into the inventory with a greater than 3.1% ahead yield in charge and at 0.80x P/NAV, which is arguably probably the most horny setup I have noticed for a royalty/streamer of this measurement with natural expansion in years.